You are correct Paau, I haven't a clue about legality thus my disclaimer many time saying I'm not a lawyer. I'm being honest. Are you a lawyer? Common be honest or does that go against a legal code.
To suggest Gowling knows nothing about legality is a stretch. There are the biggest or second biggest firm in Canada.
The fact you have even entertained the concept of going to the Supreme Court means you have accepted the possibility or inevitability that Gowling will win. You are saying even if Tenor is found to have broken the law they will not accept it.
Tenor would have gotten away with it but their greed for all the award overtook their fiduciary duty.