Welcome To The Golden Minerals HUB On AGORACOM

Golden Minerals is a junior silver producer with a strong growth profile, listed on both the NYSE Amex and TSX.

Free
Message: a review of a Wallstreet liar, is there anything else to say

a review of a Wallstreet liar, is there anything else to say

posted on Jul 30, 2008 03:01PM

THE REIGN OF THAIN HAS BEEN

ANYTHING BUT PLAIN:

We do not know

John Thain, although we met him once, by accident, on

the floor of the NYSE.. Handsome fellow, Mr. Thain. Nice

crisp suit; starched white shirt; elegant tie; good smile.

Good Harvard man as we are told. The problem is, Mr.

Thane seems to have a bit of difficulty when it comes to

informing investors about the capital situation at his firm,

Merrill Lynch, and having seen a compilation of the

comments he's made regarding Merrill's "ample" or

"sufficient, "or excess" capital we are left to conclude that

Mr. Mozilo has nothing on Mr. Thain when it comes to

making misleading statements to the public. Read then

the following comments by Mr. Thane to the media over

the course of the past eight months... and know that we

got them from Reuters, and we owe Reuter's a debt of

gratitude for them:

December 24, 2007:

One of my first priorities at Merrill Lynch was to

strengthen the firm's balance sheet, and today

we have made great progress towards that by

bolstering our capital position through these

investments and our announced sale of Merrill

Lynch Capital

.

Mr. Thain made this statement when Merrill was

announcing an effort to raise $6.2 billion in new capital.

One might have felt reasonably assured that that $6.2

billion would be Merrill's last necessary trip to the capital

trough. One would have been wrong, however..

January 15, 2008

These transactions make certain that Merrill is

well-capitalised

.

Mr. Thain made this statement after Merrill had finished

selling $6.6 billion of preferred shares to a group of

primarily Japanese and Kuwaiti investors. One might

have felt reasonably assured that this $6.6 billion would

be Merrill's last necessary trip to the capital trough. One

would have been wrong, however.

January 18, 2008

We are very confident that we have the

capital base now that we need to go forward

in 2008

.

Mr. Thane made this comment to The New York Times

that day. One might have felt reasonably assured that

Merrill' capital was unimpaired and that further trips to the

capital trough would not be necessary. One would have

been wrong, however.

March 16, 2008.

We have more capital than we need, so we can

say to the market that we don't need more

injections. We can confirm that we have tackled

the problem

This was Mr. Thain speaking to El Pais, a leading

newspaper in Spain, and one might have felt reasonably

assured that Merrill's capital was sufficient to meet all

current and future needs given the clarity of Mr. Thain's

comments. One would have been wrong, however.

March 18, 2008

Today I can say that we will not need additional

funds. These problems are behind us. We will not

return to the market.

Mr. Thain's comment this time was in an interview with

France's Le Figaro newspaper, so we can at least say

that Mr. Thain has embraced globalisation with some real

sense of enthusiasm, and further one might have felt

reasonably assured that Merrill's capital was sufficient to

meet all demands put upon it. One would have been

wrong however.

April 4th, 2008.

In 2007, we lost $8.6 billion after tax, but we

raised $12.8 billion in new capital. We raised

significantly more capital than we lost. And we

did that on purpose so that we could say to the

marketplace that we raised more than enough

capital. We replaced all the capital we lost. We

have plenty of capital going forward, and we

don't need to come back into the equity market.

The goal is to maintain our current ratings. No

more capital raising; I'm sure we have enough

capital.

This "capital" idea was put forth by Mr. Thain in an

interview with Japan's Nihon Keizai Shimbun, and

certainly by being able to raise $12.8 billion in new

capital, of which $4.2 was new "net" capital, one might

have felt reasonably assured that Merrill's capital picture

was clear and certain... finally. One would have been

wrong, however.

Four days later, on the 8th of April, which the world's

attention should have been upon the Master's

tournament, Mr. Thain said.

We deliberately raised more capital than we lost

last year ... we believe that will allow us to not

have to go back to the equity market in the

foreseeable future.

Mr. Thain made that comment when speaking to reporters

in Tokyo, and by now... certainly by now!... one would

have felt reasonably certain that Merrill's capital picture

was bright and clear. One would have been wrong,

however..

June 17, 2008

Today on a pro forma basis we have about $44

billion of equity capital, which actually isn't very

much below the all-time high that Merrill ever

had. And our philosophy about this is that we are

well-capitalized. We're comfortable with our

capital position. We, like everyone else, are

deleveraging our balance sheet.

This was Mr. Thain on a conference call hosted by

Deutsche Bank explaining some of Merrill's most recent

capital market operations. With $44 billion of "equity

capital," and assured by Mr. Thain of that fact, one might

have felt reasonably assured that Merrill's capital

structure was perfected, but one would have been wrong,

however.

Finally, on the 17th of July.... only a week and one half

ago, Mr. Thain said,

Right now we believe that we are in a very

comfortable spot in terms of our capital.

Sadly, it was not just Mr. Thain that has caused the

capital markets a bit of confusion. Merrill's President, Mr.

Greg Fleming, said of him that

John Thain has been very clear that we have

sufficient capital and don't have a need to raise

additional common equity for the foreseeable

future. When we raised this capital in January,

we had a lot of demand so we went beyond what

we needed

.

The fact is, no they did not, for Merrill was back in the

market yesterday. looking for new and permanent capital.

They found it in Temasek... fortunately. One might feel

reasonably assured.... Well, you get the picture!.

Share
New Message
Please login to post a reply