Thats a great start sir ! All I ask is that you flesh out your argument. Its not up to me to judge your work. Your entitled to your opinion. If your going to disagree or even slag me, then great. Just back it up. Incidentally I have been bashed by many and much better than most while within the executive suite. My skin is pretty thick.
The only thing that I ask is that when I throw something up, its usually got a nugget or two in it and its to be discussed debated etc. Further that there may be something i know from the industry that you don't that is behind it as well.