"You said you talked to management and they said they thought it would pop to $5 with the BTD news"

I have no reason not to believe that someone in management said that to you. Why is that so hard to believe ?Would management not have some expectation on what BTD status would do to the SP? Is it somehow material or against any rule for them to have an expectation & share it after the fact? I don't think so, not a big deal either way IMO.

glta