No I don't think so....I am rather disappointed. It may turn out well but he has been turned off on the market including PM and so lost out on a lot of movement. I would rather have a subscription to HRA but am waiting to find someone to share the cost with me as its expensive. If you would like to see what his weekly commentary looks like I would be glad to share the latest with you if you want to share you email just send me a message with it.