My take is that no one is right all of the time, but the best decisively admit their errors - as opposed to painting them over as if they didn't happen. I'm not a Skarica subscriber but I listen to his audios on howestreet. I don't recall him clearly admitting that he was wrong about his breakout call. But if I had to pick one short/medium term timer for best accuracy, I guess it would be Hulbert. And his sentiment indicator based gold calls are free on Marketwatch.com. I emphasize his technique isn't a big picture (long term) approach, but rather a swing trader's roadmap.