Yes, VK, Roy has been very consistent, informative, patient, and thoughtful... but I don't think he wants the job! Moreover, Roy can speculate far more than an employee of the company ever could - he doesn't represent/speak-for the company, so of course he's able to communicate more often and with less coinstraint.

We're not voting between Nazima and Roy, we're voting Nazima or "other"...

I tend to agree, Nazima has been fine, given what she is and is not allowed to communicate. I see no need for a change in IR, at least at that level of the food-chain.

M