363 Text
posted on
Apr 29, 2009 07:18PM
Samuel C. Straight (7638)
Ryan B. Bell (9956)
RAY QUINNEY & NEBEKER, P.C.
36 South State Street, Suite 1400
Salt Lake City, Utah 84111
Telephone: (801) 532-1500
Attorneys for Defendant e.Digital Corporation
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF UTAH CENTRAL DIVISION |
|
DIGECOR, INC., a Washington corporation, Plaintiff, v. E.DIGITAL CORPORATION, a Delaware corporation, Defendant. |
DEFENDANT’S OBJECTIONS TO DIGECOR’S APRIL 15, 2009 SUPPLEMENTAL RULE 26(a)(3) DISCLOSURES Civil Case No. 02:06-CV-00437 Judge Clark Waddoups |
Defendant e.Digital Corporation submits its Objections to digEcor’s April 15, 2009 Supplemental Rule 26(a)(3) disclosures as follows:1
Exhibit |
Objection |
1.
|
May 10, 2007 Email chain between Volker Menges and Richard Hosey, EDIGITAL 071076-80. |
2.
|
January 25, 2007 email between Fred Falk and Mr. |
1 E.Digital incorporates herein the general objections stated in its April 15, 2009 Objections to digEcor’s Pre-Trial Disclosures, Doc. #337.
Ilias at MAS, EDIGITAL 071068-70. |
|||
3.
|
October 15, 2007 email between Terry Wiseman and William Blakeley, EDIGITAL 071083-84. |
||
4.
|
May 31, 2007 email from Brent Wood to Franz Yvelin, digEcor 001801. |
||
5.
|
February 9, 2007 email from Brent Wood to Philippe Monnier, digEcor 001875. |
||
6.
|
November 28, 2007 email from Brent Wood to Franz Yvelin, e.Digital 046732-34. |
Hearsay, foundation |
|
7.
|
January 24, 2007 email from Fred Falk to Paola Magliuolo, Deposition Exhibit 322. |
||
8.
|
October 17, 2007 email chain between William Blakeley and KLM, Deposition Exhibit 328. |
||
9.
|
e.Digital’s Motion to Dismiss (Dkt. 5) and supporting memorandum (dkt. 8) |
Foundation, hearsay, legal argument |
|
10.
|
digEcor’s Opposition to e.Digital’s Motion to Dismiss (dkt. 18). |
Foundation, hearsay, legal argument |
|
11.
|
e.Digital’s Reply Memorandum to e.Digital’s Motion to Dismiss (dkt. 32). |
Foundation, hearsay, legal argument |
|
12.
|
Memorandum Decision dated January 19, 2007 (Dkt. 65). |
||
13.
|
digEcor’s Motion for Partial Summary Judgment filed April 25, 2007 (Dkt. 69) and Memorandum Supporting digEcor’s Motion for Partial Summary Judgment (Dkt. 70). |
Foundation, hearsay, legal argument |
|
2
14.
|
Reply to digEcor’s Motion for Partial Summary judgment (Dkt. 110). |
Foundation, hearsay, legal argument |
|
15.
|
August 14, 2006 email chain between Richard Hosey and S.W. Bae, EDIGITAL 071057-59. |
||
16.
|
November 21, 2006 email between Richard Hosey and S. W. Bae, EDIGITAL 071060-61. |
||
17.
|
August 28, 2006 Letter from David Tufts to Rick Hoggard. |
||
18.
|
August 4, 2006 Letter from David Tufts to Rick Hoggard. |
||
19.
|
June 29, 2006 Letter from David Tufts to Rick Hoggard. |
||
20.
|
e.Digital press release dated December 22, 2005, Deposition exhibit 81. |
||
21.
|
RFQ for digEplayer Manufacturing to Wolf Electronix, Wolf000001-05. |
Hearsay, foundation |
|
22.
|
Prequote Audit Checklist, Wolf 000006. |
Hearsay, foundation |
|
23.
|
Ethernet daughter Car, Wolf 000007-08. |
Hearsay, foundation |
|
24.
|
IFE Main Board Assembly, Wolf 000009-12. |
Hearsay, foundation |
|
25.
|
Budgetary Costing for digEplayer, Wolf 000013. |
Hearsay, foundation |
|
26.
|
Component Side Layer 1, Wolf 000014. |
Hearsay, foundation |
|
27.
|
Component Side 1 Shown, Wolf 000015. |
Hearsay, foundation |
|
28.
|
Photographs, Wolf 000016-21. |
Hearsay, foundation |
|
29.
|
Mutual Confidentility |
Hearsay, foundation |
|
3
Agreement, Wolf 000024-30. |
|||
30.
|
PO CJ5BVPA dated 2/4/2005, digEcor 001286. |
Foundation |
|
31.
|
PO CJ5BVVA dated 2/25/2005, digEcor 001288. |
Foundation |
|
32.
|
PO CJ5DW6XJB dated 4/7/2005, digEcor 001291. |
Foundation |
|
33.
|
PO CJ5DW9W dated 4/18/2005, digEcor 001293. |
Foundation |
|
34.
|
PO CJ5JXFAJL dated 8/18/2005, digEcor 001293. |
Foundation |
|
35.
|
POCJ5JXFAJL dated 8/18/2005, digEcor 001297 |
Foundation |
|
36.
|
PO CJ5JXLWJL dated 8/31/2005, digEcor 001298 |
Foundation |
|
37.
|
PO CJ5JXLWJL dated 8/31/2005, digEcor 001299. |
Foundation |
|
38.
|
PO CJ5LY9RCW dated 10/31/2005, digEcor 001299. |
Foundation |
|
39.
|
PO TJ4MUSF dated 11/15/2004, digEcor 001310. |
Foundation |
|
40.
|
PO TJ4MUUQ dated 11/19/2004, digEcor 001310. |
Foundation |
|
41.
|
PO CJ5JXKWJL dated 8/31/2005, digEcor 002226. |
Foundation |
|
42.
|
e.Digital’s SEC 10-K for Fiscal Year Ended March 31, 2002, e.Digital 033471-033575 |
||
43.
|
e.Digital’s SEC 10-K for Fiscal year Ended march 31, 2003, e.Digital 033340-70. |
||
44.
|
e.Digital’s SEC 10-K for Fiscal Year Ended March 31, 2004, e.Digital 033196-33339. |
||
45.
|
e.Digital’s SEC 10-K for Fiscal Year Ended March 31, 2005, |
||
4
e.Digital 033104-033195. |
|||
46.
|
e.Digital’s SEC 10-K for Fiscal Year Ended March 31, 2006, e.Digital 032953-033103. |
||
47.
|
e.Digital’s SEC 10-K for Fiscal Year Ended March 31, 2007, e.Digital 032800-032952. |
||
48.
|
e.Digital’s SEC 10-K for Fiscal Year Ended March 31, 2008. |
||
49.
|
Any other Form 10-K, 10-Q, or other SEC or public filing by e.Digital from 2002 to the present. |
Overly broad, vague and non-specific |
|
50.
|
PO TJ4 MURL dated 11/9/2004, digEcor 001303. |
Foundation |
|
51.
|
PO TJ4MUSD dated 11/15/2004, digEcor 001304. |
Foundation |
|
52.
|
PO TJ4MUSE dated 11/15/2004, digEcor 001305. |
Foundation |
|
53.
|
PO TJMUSQ dated 11/15/2004, digEcor 001307-08. |
Foundation |
|
54.
|
PO CJ5AVCF dated 1/11/2005, digEcor 001307-08. |
Foundation |
|
55.
|
PO TJMUSR dated 11/15/2004, digEcor 001309. |
Foundation |
|
56.
|
PO TJ4NUZ6 dated 12/06/2004, digEcor 001311. |
Foundation |
|
57.
|
PO TJ4NUZE dated 12/07/2004, digEcor 001312. |
Foundation |
|
58.
|
PO TJ4NV22 dated 12/09/2004, digEcor 001312. |
Foundation |
|
59.
|
PO CJ5BVQV dated 2/09/2004, digEcor 001287. |
Foundation |
|
60.
|
PO TJ5BVV9 dated 2/25/2005, |
Foundation |
|
5
digEcor 001314. |
|||
61.
|
PO CJ5CW5E dated 3/28/2005, digEcor 001289. |
Foundation |
|
62.
|
PO CJ5DWDA dated 4/29/2005, digEcor 001292. |
Foundation |
|
63.
|
PO CJ5EWPP dated 5/23/2005, digEcor 001294. |
Foundation |
|
64.
|
PO CJ5FWQW dated 6/12/2005, digEcor 001295. |
Foundation |
|
65.
|
PO CJ5FWQW dated 6/1/2005, digEcor 001296. |
Foundation |
|
66.
|
PO TJ5JXGGCW dated 8/23/2005, digEcor 001296. |
Foundation |
|
67.
|
PO CJ5JXKYJL dated 8/31/2005, digEcor 001300. |
Foundation |
|
68.
|
PO CJ5MYEFJL dated 11/17/2005, digEcor 001302. |
Foundation |
|
69.
|
2/22/05 email chain between F. Falk and B. Wood, digEcor 003737. |
||
70.
|
2/23/06 email chain between F. Falk and B. Wood, digEcor 03746-47. |
||
71.
|
3/2/06 email chain between F. Falk and B. Wood, digEcor 06930-42. |
Hearsay, foundation |
|
72.
|
3/2/06 email between F. Falk and B. Wood, digEcor 054944. |
Hearsay, foundation |
|
73.
|
3/2/06 email between C. Wood and F. Falk, digEcor 001190. |
Hearsay, foundation |
|
74.
|
3/9/06 email between B. Wood and F. Falk, digEcor 003813. |
Hearsay, foundation |
|
75.
|
3/9/06 email between F. Falk and C. Wood, digEcor 003014-15. |
Hearsay, foundation |
|
76.
|
3/3/06 email chain between F. |
Hearsay, foundation, legal argument |
|
6
Falk and C. Wood, digEcor 006943-47. |
||
77.
|
Any document identified by e.Digital in its pre-trial disclosures on its defamation and tortious interference claims or in any other pre-trial disclosures filed or to-be-filed in this case. |
Overly broad, vague and non-specific |
DATED this 29th day of April, 2009.
RAY, QUINNEY & NEBEKER
/s/ Ryan B. Bell
Samuel C. Straight
Ryan B. Bell
Attorneys for Defendant e.Digital Corporation
7
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that on this 29th day of April, 2009, I electronically filed the foregoing DEFENDANT’S OBJECTIONS TO DIGECOR’S APRIL 15, 2009 SUPPLEMENTAL RULE 26(a)(3) DISCLOSURES with the Clerk of Court using the CM/ECF System, which sent notification of such filing to the following:
David W. Tufts
DURHAM JONES & PINEGAR
111 E. Broadway, Suite 900
Salt Lake City, Utah 84111
/s/ Lisa Bonnell
1030998
8