If one of ordinary skill in the art would have purchased a Flashback product , he or she would have an access
to the technical information disclosed in Mr Norris declaration.One of ordinary skill in the art could have
easily disassembled the Flashback and identified the components of the product that are depicted in the
picture of the disassembled flashback attached to exhibit D to the Norris declaration.
and just as Messrs Maltiel and Norris declared , those pictures depict components that in fact use RAM
to process the audio signal for storage on the flash memory module, which could have been confirmed by
simply investigating the identified component module numbers.
In other words , the Flashback product uses RAM , in addition to flash memory and this rather unremarkable
fact could have been readily investigated by a person of ordinary skill in the art , or quite frankly, readily
appreciated base on a person of ordinary skill in arts well known understanding of how the processing
audio information occurred back at the time of invention and still occurs today !
