Has your opinion changed from your post last night????
Not at all.
As explained by those with the requisite knowledge and experience, the examiner, for whatever reason, is unable or unwilling to acknowledge the correct interpretation of the clocks.
Working backwards, if his interpretation of the clocking system is inaccurate, the rest of the argument fails ie he started with a conclusion and articulated his version in an attempt to substantiate it, in my very humble opinion.
I hope the expedited appeal documents are being composed as I type and are sent without further delay.
Be well