The link you provided gave a direct statement of fact by ronran, there is no interpretation, nor other side, unless you are somehow challenging the veracity of his statement of fact.

http://agoracom.com/ir/patriot/forums/discussion/topics/429428-is-this-an-example-of-poor-shareholder-value/messages/1406616#message

There is a gulf of difference between an opinion based on then available facts, and the facts themselves.

Given the date of his statement of fact, not only were all his holdings at nil cost, there was also the "healthy profit", notwithstanding the 8 cents per share subsequently received.

How are his stated facts an example of his often mentioned failure to provide shareholder value?

.

.

.

Be well