And I agree with you regarding the "non-controllable" term and I'm on record for the past 1.5 years saying as much. The controllable section regarding the reference crystal is what the Respondents are arguing, which you know. I just re-read the Markman transcript for pages 32 to 110 and I think this needs a trial. Magar and Sheets are really old prior art going back to the mid-80s. I'm hopeful the ALJ will see this our way and go down to the nanometer level because I think all of these companies use the innate properties of the ring oscillator to drive CPUs. Talk to me tomorrow and I'll let you know what I think then.