Free
Message: LL

LL

posted on Aug 08, 2007 12:49PM

Check out OPTI which is doing what EDIG is about to do and then look at their PPS change over the past two years. I have posted about OPTI before regarding their patent infringement suits. I don't think they have received any settlements yet but I might be mistaken.

And while you're looking into that for interest sake, check out the settlement action history below.

Damage Awards:

Damages awards in U.S. patent infringement cases reach magnitudes rarely seen in other countries. During the last decade, there have been about 20 to 30 patent infringement cases a year with published judicial awards of calculated infringement damages. Of these individual cases, about 60% had awards in excess of $1 million dollars, with over 20 ranging between $10 and $100 million dollars and at least 6 more above $100 million dollars. Nearly 20% of the total awards is attributable to pre- and post-judgment interest on the actual damages. For those cases where damages are based on a reasonable royalty, over 70% used a royalty rate in excess of 6%, with about 15% exceeding a 20% royalty rate.

Examples of Recoveries:

Award Year Parties Type Industry Source
$94,800,000 2005 Advanced Medical Optics vs. Alcon Patent Lawsuit Medical NYT0505
$60,000,000 2005 Immersion vs. Sony Patent Lawsuit Software NLJ0503
$51,000,000 2005 Medtronic vs. BrainLAB A.G. Patent Lawsuit Medical NLJ0510
$1,350,000,000 2005 Karlin Technology vs. Medtronics Patent Settlement Medical NYT0504
$325,000,000 2005 EMC vs. Hewlett Packard Patent Settlement Computers WSJ0505
$40,000,000 2005 Soverain Software vs. Amazon Patent Settlement Software NLJ0508
$8,000,000 2005 Yahoo vs. Miva Patent Settlement Software SFC0508
$1,800,000 2005 Univs. Texas vs. RIM Patent Settlement Software SCI0508
$1,300,000 2004 Elan vs. Eisai Patent Buyout Pharmaceuticals NYT0404
$55,000,000 2004 Elan vs. Vernalis Patent Buyout Pharmaceuticals NYT0404
$134,500,000 2004 Masimo vs. Tyco Nellcor Patent Lawsuit Medical KMOB news
$43,500,000 2004 Applied Medical Resources vs. Tyco U.S. Surgical Patent Lawsuit Medical KMOB news
$8,670,000 2004 Microtune vs. Broadcom Patent Lawsuit Electronics NLJ0405
$3,500,000 2004 Golden Voice Technology vs. Rockwell Electronic Patent lawsuit Software Web news
$5,000,000 2004 Nastech vs. Merck Patent Licence Pharmaceutical SFC0409
$225,000,000 2004 Intergraph vs. Intel Patent Settlement Electronics SFC0403
$78,000,000 2004 Chiron vs. Roche Holdings Patent Settlement Medical WSJ04091
$40,000,000 2004 Ampex vs. Sony Patent Settlement Software SFC0411
$8,000,000 2004 Novellus vs. Applied Materials Patent Settlement Electronics WSJ0409
$25,000,000 2003 St. Clair Intellectual Property vs. Sony Patent Lawsuit Electronics news story
$12,200,000 2003 Poly-America vs. GSE Lining Technology Patent Lawsuit Mechanical INT007
$12,000,000 2003 Philip Jackson vs. Glenayre Electronics Patent Lawsuit Electronics NLJ0403
$7,400,000 2003 Ralph Benghiat vs. Itron Inc. Patent Lawsuit Electronics NLJ0103
$1,900,000 2003 Mattel vs. Safety1st/Dorel Patent Lawsuit Mechanical NYT0103a
$330,000,000 2003 Idenix Pharmaceuticals vs. Novartis Patent License Drugs WSJ0303
$295,000,000 2003 Eli Lilly vs. Galen Holdings Patent License Drugs GEN0103
$62,500,000 2003 Hilgraeve vs. Symantec Patent Settlement Software WSJ0308
$60,000,000 2003 SPX Corp. vs. Microsoft Patent Settlement Software NYT0312
$49,500,000 2003 Tulip Computers vs. Dell Computer Patent Settlement Electronics

detnews.com/
2003/technology/0307

$34,000,000 2003 InterDigital Comm. vs. Ericsson Patent Settlement Electronics HR0303
$25,000,000 2003 Nortel Networks vs. Ciena Patent Settlement Electronics INT002
$17,000,000 2003 TDK vs. Silicon Laboratories Patent Settlement Electronics INT008
$15,000,000 2003 Interpore vs. Johnson & Johnson Patent Settlement Medical NYT0103
$6,000,000 2003 Proxim vs. Intersil Patent Settlement Electronics INT009
$475,000,000 2002 SpinBrush Inc. vs. Procter & Gamble Patent Buyout Mechanical BW0802
$453,000,000 2002 InterTrust vs. Sony, Philips Patent Buyout Software WSJ1102c
$380,000,000 2002 Immunex vs. Schering AG Patent Buyout Drugs WSJ0502a
$24,000,000 2002 Unova vs. Broadcom Patent Buyout Electronics NYT1202
$7,000,000 2002 Liquid Audio vs. Microsoft Patent Buyout Software SFC1002
$1,000,000 2002 Storage Engine vs. Veritas Software Patent Buyout Software INT003
$505,000,000 2002 Igen International vs. Roche Holding Patent Lawsuit Drugs WSJ0102
$500,000,000 2002 City of Hope Nat Med Cent vs. Genentech Patent Lawsuit Drugs SFC0602a
$424,000,000 2002 Medical Instrument. vs. Elekta Patent Lawsuit Medical INT006
$158,000,000 2002 Guidant vs. Medtronic Patent Lawsuit Medical NYT0402a
$150,000,000 2002 Intergraph vs. Intel Patent Lawsuit Electronics WSJ1102d
$114,000,000 2002 Internet Magic vs. Netfax Patent Lawsuit Software NLJ0202b
$98,100,000 2002 B.J. Services vs. Halliburton Patent Lawsuit Chemical NLJ0402a
$63,500,000 2002 Aruze Corp. vs. Sammy Corp. Patent Lawsuit Electronics IPT0602
$61,000,000 2002 Harris Corp. vs. Ericsson Patent Lawsuit Electronics Dallas Business Journal 28 Nov 2002 Dallas Business Journal 28 Nov 2002
$57,000,000 2002 Univs. Colorado vs. American Cyanamid Patent Lawsuit Chemical NLJ0802a
$52,600,000 2002 Applera/MDS vs. Waters Corp. Patent Lawsuit Chemical WSJ0502c
$47,500,000 2002 Applied Biosystems/MDX vs. Micromass Patent Lawsuit Electronics NLJ0402b
$36,500,000 2002 Atmel vs. Silicon Storage Patent Lawsuit Electronics EN0502
$32,600,000 2002 Bristol Myers Squibb vs. Aventis Patent Lawsuit Chemical NLJ0802b
$23,100,000 2002 NTP Inc. vs. Research in Motion Patent Lawsuit Electronics WSJ1102a
$28,500,000 2002 Harry Gaus vs. Conair Corp. Patent Lawsuit Electronics NLJ0202a
$27,200,000 2002 Inter. Rectifier vs. IXYS Patent Lawsuit Electronics INT010
$25,000,000 2002 Fuji Photo Film vs. Jazz Photo Patent Lawsuit Cameras NLJ1202
$25,000,000 2002 Honeywell vs. Borg Warner Patent Lawsuit Mechanical WSJ0702
$17,437,220 2002 BIC Corp. vs. ERA International Patent Lawsuit Mechanical 00-CA-7155 (SDNY 27 Feb 2002)
$17,400,000 2002 X-IT Products vs. Walter Kidde Patent Lawsuit Mechanical NLJ0901
$17,200,000 2002 Alcon Inc vs. Nidek Co. Patent Lawsuit Electronics INT004
$10,000,000 2002 Syndia vs. Gillette Patent Lawsuit Mechanical NYT0602a
$7,400,000 2002 Telemac Corp. vs. USIntellicom Patent Lawsuit Electronics NLJ0402
$4,900,000 2002 Macromedia vs. Adobe Systems Patent Lawsuit Software SFC0502
$4,400,000 2002 Intuitive Surgical/IBM vs. Computer Motion Patent Lawsuit Surgical NYT0802
$4,200,000 2002 MKS Instruments vs. Advanced Energy Patent Lawsuit Chemical NLJ0602
$2,820,000 2002 Adobe Systems vs. Macromedia Patent Lawsuit Software SFC0502
$2,100,000 2002 Control Alt Design vs. Tensor Corp. Patent Lawsuit Electronics NLJ0102a
$2,000,000 2002 nCube vs. SeaChange International Patent Lawsuit Electronics ZDNET
$325,000,000 2002 Amylin Pharmaceuticals vs. Eli Lilly Patent License Drugs NYT0902
$135,000,000 2002 Genta vs. Aventis Patent License Drugs WSJ0402b
$28,500,000 2002 InterTrust vs. Sony Patent License Software WSJ0502b
$26,000,000 2002 Cell Genesys vs. Transkaryotic Therapies Patent License Drugs SFBJ0602
$300,000,000 2002 Intergraph vs. Intel Patent Settlement Electronics WSJ0402a
$175,000,000 2002 Boston Scientific vs. Medtronic Patent Settlement Medical NYT0902a
$53,000,000 2002 InterDigital Communications vs. NEC Patent Settlement Electronics NYT0102a
$30,000,000 2002 eSpeed vs. CBOT and CME Patent Settlement Software INT013
$30,000,000 2002 ADC Telecommunications vs. Thomas & Betts Patent Settlement Electronics NLJ0502a
$25,000,000 2002 Fischer Imaging vs. Thermo Electron Patent Settlement Medical PRNewswire
$24,000,000 2002 Business Objects SA vs. Cognos Patent Settlement Software WSJ0502d
$20,000,000 2002 Varian Semiconductor vs. Lam Research Patent Settlement Electronic EN0102
$20,000,000 2002 Berlex Laboratories vs. Biogen Patent Settlement Drugs NLJ0202
$18,000,000 2002 DepoMed vs. Bristol Myers Squibb Patent Settlement Drugs INT012
$15,000,000 2002 3Com vs. Xircom Patent Settlement Electronics WSJ1102e
$15,000,000 2002 Jupiter Media Metrix vs. NetRatings Patent Settlement Software WSJ0502
$3,750,000 2002 Datascope vs. Vascular Solutions Patent Settlement Medical INT011
$2,000,000 2002 Digimarc vs. Verance Patent Settlement Software Digimarc
$169,000,000 2001 Boston Scientific vs. Medtronic Patent Arbitrate Medical WSJ07011
$170,000,000 2001 Gilead Sciences vs. OSI Pharmaceuticals Patent Buyout Drug SFC1101
$40,000,000 2001 Lernout & Hauspie vs. ScanSoft Patent Buyout Electronics NYT1101
$140,000,000 2001 Guidant vs. St. Jude Medical Patent Lawsuit Medical WSJ0701
$78,000,000 2001 Southern Clay Products vs. Sued-Chemie Patent Lawsuit Chemicals IPT0301
$46,580,000 2001 Honeywell vs. Hamilton Sundstrand Patent Lawsuit Mechanical NLJ00301
$35,000,000 2001 Crystal Semiconductor vs. Tritech Microelectronics Patent Lawsuit Electronic CAFC0301
$17,530,000 2001 Osteotech vs. Gensci Regeneration Patent Lawsuit Medical NLJ0102
$15,000,000 2001 IPPV Enterprises vs. Echostar DISH Patent Lawsuit Software NLJ0102
$10,600,000 2001 Tanashin Denki vs. Thomson Consumer Electronics Patent Lawsuit Electronics NLJ1101
$8,700,000 2001 William Riles vs. Shell Exploration Patent Lawsuit Mechanical NLJ0401
$8,300,000 2001 Boston Scientific vs. Johnson & Johnson Patent Lawsuit Medical WSJ0901
$7,000,000 2001 Harris vs. Sanyo Patent Lawsuit Electronics NLJ1001
$3,000,000 2001 Carberry Corp. vs. Land O'Lakes Inc. Patent Lawsuit Chemical NYT0102
$2,000,000 2001 Lamps Plus vs. Catalina Lighting Patent Lawsuit Mechanical NLJ04012
$1,500,000 2001 Acres Gaming vs. Mikohn Gaming Patent Lawsuit Software NLJ04011
$1,400,000 2001 Internet Pictures vs. iMove Inc. Patent Lawsuit Software IntPic
$1,015,180 2001 Micro Chemical vs. Lextron Patent Lawsuit Software NLJ07011
$1,000,000 2001 Great Lakes Chemical vs. Archimica Patent Lawsuit Pharmaceutical NLJ0201
$187,000,000 2001 OSI Pharmaceuticals vs. Genentech,Roche Patent License Drugs WSJ01011
$34,500,000 2001 Hybridon vs. Isis Patent License Biotech GEN0601
$18,000,000 2001 BioTime vs. Akzo Nobel Patent License Pharmaceutical SFC0201
$6,000,000 2001 Isis vs. Hybridon Patent License Biotech GEN0601
$420,000,000 2001 Litton Industries vs. Honeywell Patent Settlement Electronics AWST0993
$400,000,000 2001 Pitney Bowes vs. HP Patent Settlement Software WSJ0601
$15,800,000 2001 Ricoh vs. Nashua Corp. Patent Settlement Mechanical NLJ01012
$10,000,000 2001 Nova Biomedical vs. i-STAT Patent Settlement Medical IPT0901
$5,000,000 2001 Motorola vs. Nanogen Patent Settlement Biotech NLJ0801
$324,000,000 2000 Cordis/Johnson & Johnson vs. Boston Scientific Patent Lawsuit Medical WSJ12001
$270,000,000 2000 Cordis/Johnson & Johnson vs. Medtronic Patent Lawsuit Medical WSJ12002
$68,750,000 2000 General Technology Apps. vs. Conoco Liquid Power Patent Lawsuit Chemicals WP0500
$18,000,000 2000 Edmark Industries vs. S. Asia Intn'l Patent Lawsuit Mechanical NLJ0900
$18,000,000 2000 SIBIA vs. Cadus Pharmaceuticals Patent Lawsuit Pharmaceutical NLJ1000
$16,350,000 2000 Integra Lifesciences vs. Merck KgaA Patent Lawsuit Biotech NLJ10001
$13,200,000 2000 Frank Calabrese vs. Square D Patent Lawsuit Software NYT0200
$13,000,000 2000 C.R. Bard vs. Boston Scientific Patent Lawsuit Medical NLJ10001
$11,750,000 2000 Heidelberg Harris vs. Mitsubishi Heavy Industry Patent Lawsuit Mechanical Heidelberg v. Mitsubishi, 56 USPQ2d 1714
$11,000,000 2000 Smith Engineering vs. Eisenmann Corp. Patent Lawsuit Mechanical NLJ07000
$5,700,000 2000 Bose vs. Harman Inter. Patent Lawsuit Mechanical NLJ09001
$4,200,000 2000 Quickturn Design vs. Aptiz Patent Lawsuit Legal fees NLJ09001
$2,218,000 2000 Tate Access Floors vs. Maxcess Technologies Patent Lawsuit Mechanical NLJ09002
$100,000,000 2000 Chiron vs. Hoffman-LaRoche Patent License Biotech BW0600
$100,000,000 2000 Abbott vs. Cephalon Patent License Drugs GEN1100
$80,000,000 2000 ETRI vs. Qualcomm Patent Royalties Electronics WSJ1200
$200,000,000 2000 Gemstar vs. Motorola Patent Settlement Electronics NLJ11001
$25,000,000 2000 Lubrizol vs. Imperial Patent Settlement Chemical NLJ11002
$25,000,000 2000 Bausch & Lomb vs. Alcon Laboratories Patent Settlement Chemical CHW0200
$20,000,000 2000 Xilinx vs. Altera Patent Settlement Electronic SJMN0701
$8,000,000 2000 SanDisk < Lexar Patent Settlement Electronics EN1100
$6,300,000 2000 Dyson Appliances vs. Hoover Patent Settlement Mechanical INT005
$4,250,000 2000 Serta vs. Simmons Patent Settlement Mechanical NLJ01011
$2,000,000 2000 Lexar < SanDisk Patent Settlement Electronics EN1100
$165,000,000 1999 Viskase Corp. vs. American National Can Patent Lawsuit Chemicals NLJ04001
$154,000,000 1999 Hughes Aircraft vs. US Government Patent Lawsuit Electronics Fed. Cl. No. 426-73
$47,900,000 1999 AcroMed vs. Sofamor Danek Patent Lawsuit Medical NLJ02002
-$40,000,000 1999 AccuScan vs. Xerox Patent Lawsuit Electronics ACCUSCAN
$32,300,000 1999 Power Integration vs. Motorola Patent Lawsuit Electronics EET1099
$29,000,000 1999 Int. Game Tech. vs. WMS Gaming Patent Lawsuit Electronics NLJ12991
$25,200,000 1999 Tec Air vs. Denso Manufacturing Patent Lawsuit Chemical 52 USPQ2d 1294
$20,000,000 1999 Crystal Semiconductor vs. Opti Inc. Patent Lawsuit Electronics NLJ02001
$12,900,000 1999 General Surgical vs. Guidant Patent Lawsuit Medical NLJ0800
$12,500,000 1999 Intermatic vs. Lamson & Sessions Patent Lawsuit Mechanical NLJ1099
$9,500,000 1999 Lucent vs. Newbridge Networks Patent Lawsuit Electronics IPT0100
$5,400,000 1999 Guidant vs. Medtronic Patent Lawsuit Medical NLJ1299
$3,100,000 1999 CFM Technologies vs. Steag Electronics Patent Lawsuit Electronic EN1199
$2,700,000 1999 SunTiger vs. Scientific Research Facility Patent Lawsuit Optics BANWIT
$1,000,000 1999 Interactive Pictures vs. Infinite Pictures Patent Lawsuit Software BANWIT
$300,000,000 1999 Univs. Minnesota vs. Glaxo Wellcome Patent Settlement Drug WSJ1099
$200,000,000 1999 Univs. California vs. Genentech Patent Settlement Drugs SFC1194
$163,500,000 1999 Procter & Gamble vs. Paragon Trade Patent Settlement Mechanical WSJ0299
$170,000,000 1998 Exxon Chemical vs. Mobil Chemical Patent Lawsuit Chemical CHW0898
$70,000,000 1998 Odetics vs. Storage Technology Patent Lawsuit Electronics ACCUSCAN
$39,200,000 1998 AlliedSignal vs. Cooper Automotive Patent Lawsuit Mechanical NLJ0798
-$36,000,000 1998 Interactive Tech. vs. Pittway/Ademco Patent Lawsuit Electronics SDM0498
$13,000,000 1998 Variable Parameter Fixture vs. Morpheus Lights Patent Lawsuit Electronic S.D.N.Y case
$12,500,000 1998 Interactive Networks vs. TCI Patent Lawsuit Software BCB0398
$1,250,000 1998 Eaton vs. Meritor Automotive Patent Lawsuit Mechanical FLO0898
$90,000,000 1998 Sepracor vs. Eli Lilly Patent License Drugs CEN1298
$13,000,000 1997 Escom/Commodore vs. Gateway Patent Buyout Electronic WSJ0899
$700,000,000 1997 Digital vs. Intel Patent Lawsuit Computer IW1197
$102,000,000 1997 Viskase vs. American National Can Patent Lawsuit Mechanical BI0997
$98,000,000 1997 Fonar Corp. vs. General Electric Patent Lawsuit Electronics MHC0397
$68,000,000 1997 Unocal vs. Six oil companies Patent Lawsuit Chemical NPN1297
$57,000,000 1997 Celeritas Tech. vs. Rockwell Patent Lawsuit Electronics LAT0197
$18,000,000 1997 Comark Communications vs. Harris Corp. Patent Lawsuit Electronics BCB0897
$13,000,000 1997 Applied Medical Resources vs. US Surgical Patent Lawsuit Medical HIT0797
$211,000,000 1996 Haworth vs. Steelcase Patent Lawsuit Mechanical FOR0197
$32,400,000 1996 SRI International vs. Advanced Technology Labs Patent Lawsuit Electronics SRI
$72,700,000 1995 Stryker Corp. vs. Intermedics Orthopedics Patent Lawsuit Medical USDC E.D.N.Y. No. CV-90-3006(ADS)
(EDNY Oct. 3, 1995)
$64,000,000 1995 Schneider/BCSI vs. Scimed Patent Lawsuit Medical BCSI
$44,000,000 1995 Haworth vs. Herman Miller Patent Lawsuit Mechanical FRB0596
$6,000,000 1995 Celeritas Tech. vs. ATT Patent Lawsuit Electronics LAT0197
$129,000,000 1994 Exxon Chemical vs. Lubrizol Patent Lawsuit Chemical CHW0394
$83,000,000 1994 Stac Electronics vs. Microsoft Patent License Software CRN0694
$48,000,000 1993 Eli Lilly vs. SciMed Patent License Medical FW0493
$14,000,000 1993 Amgen vs. Genetics Institute Patent License Biotech CMR0593
$107,000,000 1992 3M vs. Johnson & Johnson Patent Lawsuit Medical 22 USPQ2d 1401
$3,500,000 1992 Hilton Davis vs. Warner Jenkinson Patent Lawsuit Chemical CMR0195
$873,000,000 1991 Polaroid vs. Eastman Kodak Patent Lawsuit Chemical USPQ1617
$4,000,000 1991 Pharmacia AB vs. MedChem Patent Lawsuit Chemical BBJ0191
$200,000,000 1990 Intel and AMD Patent Wasted Electronics EBB0494
$125,000,000 1990 Procter & Gamble vs.> Procter & Gamble vs. Patent Lawsuit Chemical AA0990
$25,600,000 1990 Brooktree vs. AMD Patent Lawsuit Electronics EN1090
$17,000,000 1990 Modine Manufacturing vs. Allen Group Patent Lawsuit Mechanical BAR1090
$500,000,000+ 1990 Texas Instruments vs. Toshiba Patent Settlement Electronics EET1290
$20,000,000 1990 Rodime vs. IBM Patent Settlement Mechanical EN1190
$205,000,000 1986 Hughes Tool vs. Smith International Patent Lawsuit Mechanical CFO0489
$23,000,000 1985 Baker Hughes vs. Dresser Industries Patent Settlement Mechanical FRB0790
$1,300,000 1980 Laurie Visual vs. Chesebrough-Pond Patent Lawsuit Mechanical BW1180
$25,000 1953 Sony vs. ATT Bell Labs Patent License Electronics BW0407

Aug 08, 2007 02:08PM

Aug 08, 2007 02:17PM
Share
New Message
Please login to post a reply