Re:Karoo - Fracking rules will need to drill into the detail
in response to
by
posted on
Jun 25, 2015 11:30PM
Developing large acreage positions of unconventional and conventional oil and gas resources
by Nonhlalo Mphofu, June 25 2015, 05:50
LAST month, Science and Technology Minister Naledi Pandor announced the government’s plan to proceed with a strategic impact assessment and exploration of shale-gas hydraulic fracturing (fracking) in the Karoo. This is a positive sign of the government’s commitment to due diligence before fracking is permitted. Should it be found to be viable, there is no doubt, given our energy crisis, that extraction of gas will be allowed to commence.
However, failure to protect the environment and health of affected communities in the Karoo could tarnish the government’s reputation.
Ultimate dependence on our coal-powered stations for energy has resulted in economic growth in the manufacturing sector lagging behind. According to a recent report by the South African Chamber of Commerce and Industry, electricity supply disruptions have largely contributed to the decline of the business confidence index to a 16-year low.
Our energy crisis should be dealt with without further delay. The government needs to move swiftly to identify and activate enablers for economic growth, specifically energy sources. For our economy to thrive, access to adequate, affordable energy is crucial. Equally important is the need for sustainable development, and to this end the shale gas exploitation in the Karoo basin poses a dilemma. In the US, adverse public-health risks of fracking have invoked fears among affected communities, with residents of Texas calling for a ban on fracking last year.
According to a presentation by Graeme Potter, of the Dogwood Insight Center, published last year, about 750 different chemicals are used to enhance water flow, 650 of which are carcinogens. Though it is difficult to link illnesses to particular chemical exposure, some credible data collected suggested a direct relationship between increased infant mortality and the density of fracking wells. Low birth weight has also been reported among communities close to fracking wells.
Possible contamination of underground water by carcinogens and endocrine disrupters places the lives of affected communities at risk of cancer and hormonal disorders.
According to SA’s Constitution, every person has a right to an environment that is safe and free from health risks. An impediment of these rights to communities due to fracking will reflect negatively on the government. Given the current stance that the community has taken to oppose shale-gas exploration until the strategic impact assessments have been completed, the damage to the government’s reputation, should there be any adverse exposure, would be even greater.
Apart from possible health risks, the amount of water required for fracking is huge and half of it is irrecoverable. Given our meagre water resources, there is bound to be a deprivation of another human right, that of access to adequate water supply.
The government has a vital task in drafting fracking regulations that are clear and provide precise check points and resolution processes to deal with emerging risks before, during and after fracking activities. Environmental and public-health effects can be controlled through effective regulation and implementation of strict control, monitoring and remediation measures.
There is no doubt that fracking, if carried out correctly and responsibly, has enormous potential to unlock SA’s economic growth, not only through the provision of reliable energy but also through the creation of much-needed jobs.
Fortunately, we are not pioneers in fracking. Therefore, we have an opportunity to learn from the likes of the US and Canada and avert foreseeable environmental and public-health risks. Even more encouraging is the fact that fracking in the Cooper Basin of South Australia has taken place over the years without significant environmental effects.
• Mphofu is the safety, health, environment and quality executive of the Steel and Engineering Industries Federation of Southern Africa