Yes, I agree fully.  His ASM performance was not terrible, just lacked any level of excitment for the future.  Of course, the little tidbit about all the previous stuff being off the table was tough for any of us to swallow.

When speaking to Atul one-on-one, it was easier to understand him.  As a public speaker, he lacked the communications skilled.  I would imagine he was very good with tech speak to the engineering crowd.  It was just us Joe Sixpack investors and potential customers that probably had a problem understanding.

Regardless of Atul's tenure, I like Willy's world better...maybe I just have more in common with him than with Atul.

John