It may not have been unfavorable, but it was not favorable, or all of the claims constructions would have been considered.

Think about the comments coming from management at the shareholders meeting....let get out of Denver or words to that effect.

We will know to what extent the ruling had on the settlements once we see all of the quarterly data that includes the settlement amounts.

That should be an indicator of how the ruling went.

You are talking about specific technical issues, I'm looking at the overall ruling and it's impact on the company financial results.