You opined"...

"looks like a coin toss to me...lol"...

That is why your opinion is that of a "LAYMAN"...

It is ture that the judge has "Full discretion", but that does not mean she can exercise that discretion Willy-Nilly. She has to Rule in line with governing law, both Statutory and Case Law...

ONE MORE TIME:...

LAW IN NOT A CRAP SHOOT, or as you put it " a coin toss"...

Gil...